Who is Punished Most for Challenging the Status Quo?

Ody-Brasier, A and Vermeulen, F (2020) Who is Punished Most for Challenging the Status Quo? Academy of Management Journal, 63 (5). pp. 1621-1651. ISSN 0001-4273


Over time, markets evolve into particular structures, with clearly defined roles in terms of who does what in the industry. When a firm ventures beyond these established roles, it often gets punished by its exchange partners. Our interviews in the market for Champagne grapes, however, suggest that some buyers get penalized substantially more than others in response to such actions. Quantitative analysis confirms that nontraditional buyers receive price penalties for role deviations—through diversification, vertical integration, or dis-integration—whereas traditional firms are treated much more leniently. We conducted a subsequent interpretivist study, using interview data from 78 market participants, to explore the exact mechanisms underlying this effect. The analysis reveals that sellers blame less traditional buyers when they cross the boundaries of their usual roles, because they are thought to act out of volition and bad faith, whereas they believe that the same transgressions by more traditional firms must have been necessitated by external circumstances. We conclude that the sanctioning behavior of actors in response to role transgressions by their exchange partners is driven by their interpretation of the motives underlying these transgressions, rather than by the actions themselves. As a result, nontraditional firms may also find it difficult to deviate from the traditional roles in their industry.

More Details

Item Type: Article
Subject Areas: Strategy and Entrepreneurship
Additional Information:

(c) 2019 Academy of Management

Date Deposited: 23 Oct 2019 10:01
Date of first compliant deposit: 23 Oct 2019
Subjects: Selling
Bulk buying
Last Modified: 17 Jul 2024 01:45
URI: https://lbsresearch.london.edu/id/eprint/1256

Export and Share


Full text not available from this repository.


View details on Dimensions' website

Downloads from LBS Research Online

View details

Actions (login required)

Edit Item Edit Item