Using allegations to understand selection bias in organizations: Misconduct in the Chicago Police Department

Stroube, B (2021) Using allegations to understand selection bias in organizations: Misconduct in the Chicago Police Department. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 166. pp. 149-165. ISSN 0749-5978 OPEN ACCESS


Selection biases present a fundamental challenge for research on ethics and misconduct. This issue is well understood at the individual level, where lab studies are often employed to sidestep it at the potential expense of external validity. However, much archival field data on ethics and misconduct are at risk of selection bias originating from within organizations, because organizations are typically responsible for evaluating and ultimately documenting who commits misconduct. In this paper I explore the nature and potential scope of this particular form of selection bias, its potential impact on the interpretation of extant findings from the literature, and how studying allegations may help detect it in specific contexts. Using detailed data on formal allegations of police misconduct in Chicago, I highlight how status characteristics such as race and gender may bias the creation of archival data. For example, black officers received allegations at similar rates to white officers, but were more likely to have them sustained, and allegations made by black complainants were less likely to be sustained than those made by white complainants—even when including extensive sets of control variables. These findings indicate that accounting for allegations may be a fruitful methodological avenue to better understand the optimal use of archival behavioral field data for research on ethics and misconduct.

More Details

Item Type: Article
Subject Areas: Strategy and Entrepreneurship
Additional Information:

© 2020 The Authors. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons CC-BY license, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

You are not required to obtain permission to reuse this article.

Date Deposited: 24 Mar 2020 16:28
Date of first compliant deposit: 13 Mar 2020
Subjects: Selection of personnel
Discipline of members
Last Modified: 16 Jul 2024 01:59

Export and Share


Published Version - Text
  • Available under License
Supplemental Material - Text


View details on Dimensions' website

Downloads from LBS Research Online

View details

Actions (login required)

Edit Item Edit Item