The benchmark inclusion subsidy

Kashyap, A K, Kovrijnykh, N, Li, Jian and Pavlova, A (2021) The benchmark inclusion subsidy. Journal of Financial Economics, 142 (2). pp. 756-774. ISSN 0304-405X

Abstract

We argue that the pervasive practice of evaluating portfolio managers relative to a benchmark has real effects. Benchmarking generates additional, inelastic demand for assets inside the benchmark. This leads to a “benchmark inclusion subsidy:” a firm inside the benchmark values an investment project more than the one outside. The same wedge arises for valuing M&A, spinoffs, and IPOs. This overturns the proposition that an investment’s value is independent of the entity considering it. We describe the characteristics that determine the subsidy, quantify its size (which could be large), and identify empirical work supporting our model’s predictions.